Acquisitions are guilty pleasures that require management’s effort and discipline to handle properly. Today, we’ll look at common accounting issues facing controllers at early-stage companies undertaking their first acquisitions and share practical approaches to incorporating newly acquired subsidiaries into group reporting.
1. Acquisition accounting.
1.1. Which model of acquisition accounting applies to the transaction?
Management needs to assess whether the business combination guidance applies to the acquisition transactions based on the following considerations:
a) Is this a transaction under common control?
The FASB ASC does not define the term ‘common control’. The definition of common control can vary by context, requiring careful evaluation of each situation, as the ultimate determination relies heavily on professional judgment. In practice, the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) staff’s statements in EITF 02-5 are often used to provide direction for identifying common control.
Examples of situations when common control exists include:
A single beneficiary holds more than 50% of the voting ownership interest in each entity.
A group of shareholders collectively holds more than 50% of the voting ownership interest in each entity, provided there is contemporaneous written evidence of an agreement to vote a majority of the entity’s shares in concert.
When immediate family members (married couples and their children, excluding grandchildren) hold more than 50% of the voting ownership interest in each entity, provided there is no evidence of independent voting. Ownership structures involving siblings and their children require careful evaluation of both ownership and voting relationships.
b) Is this a transaction with a high degree of common ownership?
Entities may have a high degree of common ownership without being under common control. For example, a high degree of common ownership exists when multiple shareholders hold comparable interests across several entities, but no single shareholder exercises control over any of them.
In these situations, transfers between such entities do not meet the technical definition of common control transactions because the controlling-interest requirement is not satisfied. However, from an accounting perspective, if the transfer lacks economic substance, meaning it does not result in a substantive change in the rights or interests of the shareholders, such transactions may still be accounted for like common control transactions.
c) Is this a transaction with no economic substance?
Historically, the SEC staff has relied on FASB Technical Bulletin No. 85-5, Issues Relating to Accounting for Business Combinations (FTB 85-5), to assess whether a transaction lacks economic substance. In an exchange between a parent and a minority shareholder in a partially owned subsidiary, paragraph 6 states that if the minority interest remains unchanged and the combined entity's only assets are those of the subsidiary before the exchange, no change in ownership has occurred. In such cases, the transaction should be accounted for using the carrying amounts of the subsidiary’s assets and liabilities.
The SEC staff has indicated that if ownership percentages and interests are not, in substance, the same before and after a transaction, a substantive transaction has occurred. In such instances, the staff would object to accounting for the transaction as a common control transaction. Entities should account for transfers of businesses with economic substance under the acquisition method.
The SEC staff’s reviews demonstrate that even small shifts in minority ownership can have significant economic consequences and may disqualify transactions from historical cost accounting treatment. Therefore, it is necessary to assess all interests on a fully diluted basis and to evaluate additional economic factors beyond ownership percentages.
d) Is this a transaction that involves an entity that does not meet the definition of business?
Where common-control or similar carrying-value accounting does not apply, determine whether the acquired set meets ASC 805’s definition of a business. A qualifying business combination follows the acquisition method. An acquired set that does not constitute a business generally follows the asset-acquisition model under ASC 805-50.
e) Is this a transaction in which an accounting acquirer differs from the legal buyer?
Identify the accounting acquirer by determining which entity obtains control. The accounting acquirer may differ from the legal purchaser. Where it does, assess whether the transaction is a reverse business acquisition, a reverse asset acquisition, or a capital transaction. The classification depends on the substance of the transaction and whether the accounting acquiree constitutes a business.
2. Purchase Price Allocation.
2.1. What is Purchase Price Allocation?
US GAAP generally requires the acquirer to recognize identifiable assets acquired and liabilities assumed in a business combination at their acquisition-date fair values, with some limited exceptions (customer balances, deferred taxes, etc.). The acquirer must also identify intangible assets that qualify for separate recognition, including assets the seller had not recognized.
Unless the buyer has internal resources with the experience and qualifications needed to perform this type of valuation work (which is unlikely for an early-stage business), the buyer should engage an external valuation expert to value all of the acquiree’s assets and liabilities.
Management uses the valuation results and other supporting analyses to prepare the purchase price allocation (PPA). The PPA establishes the amounts recognized for identifiable assets acquired and liabilities assumed, then allocates the consideration transferred among those items. Noncontrolling interest or a previously held interest, if present, is also accounted for in this calculation. Goodwill generally equals the excess of the consideration transferred, together with the acquisition-date amounts recognized for any noncontrolling interest and previously held interest, over the recognized identifiable net assets acquired.
The identifiable net assets and goodwill establish the group’s acquisition basis. That basis is incorporated into an opening trial balance for the acquired subsidiary in consolidated reporting. As a result, the subsidiary’s opening balances for group reporting may differ from the balances maintained in its own books.
Some acquisition-date measurements may be incomplete when the group first reports the transaction. In such cases, management recognizes provisional amounts while gathering necessary information until it determines that further information is unavailable, but this period, when additional time is given to gather data, should not exceed one year from the acquisition date.
Measurement-period adjustments reflect new information about facts and circumstances that existed at the acquisition date. Management recognizes adjustments to provisional amounts with a corresponding adjustment to goodwill in the period the adjustments are determined. Any resulting changes in depreciation, amortization, or other income effects are recognized in current-period earnings as if the acquisition accounting had been completed at the acquisition date [ASC 805-10-25-17].
2.2. How should the acquirer measure the value of individual assets and liabilities?
The acquisition-date measurement requirements do not necessarily change the recorded amount of every asset or liability. In practice, we have encountered multiple situations where carrying amounts were used as a reasonable approximation of the required measurements:
Short-term receivables and payables may require limited adjustment where discounting and other valuation differences are immaterial.
Recently purchased equipment may already be recorded at fair value where the purchase price provides the best evidence of current market value.
These conclusions depend on whether the carrying amounts approximate the fair value.
Separately, ASC 805 provides exceptions to the general acquisition-date recognition and measurement rules. For items within those exceptions, management must apply the specified treatment rather than assume that fair value governs every balance. In particular:
Leases (ASC 842): Where the acquiree is the lessee, measure the lease liability using remaining lease payments and the applicable acquisition-date discount rate. Initially measure the right-of-use asset at that liability, adjusted for favorable or unfavorable terms relative to market. Historical prepaid or accrued rent balances are not carried forward. Where the acquiree is the lessor under an operating lease, favorable above-market terms generally produce an intangible asset, while unfavorable below-market terms generally produce a liability.
Customer contract balances (ASC 606): Following ASU 2021-08, customer balances in scope of ASC 606 are recognized and measured under the referenced guidance instead of fair values. The acquirer applies ASC 606 as though it had originated the acquired contracts. It must assess the seller’s accounting, including differences in policies, estimates, and judgments, as well as any errors. Consequently, the acquired balance may equal the seller’s balance unless it is assessed as inappropriate based on specific facts and circumstances. The seller’s historical contract-acquisition costs, including deferred sales commissions, generally are not carried forward as separate assets in the acquirer’s acquisition accounting.
Purchased Financial Assets with Credit Deterioration (ASC 326): For assets measured at amortized cost, add the acquisition-date credit loss allowance to the acquisition-date fair value to establish the initial amortized cost basis. Recognize the allowance separately, leaving the initial net carrying amount equal to acquisition-date fair value.
Indemnification Assets: Measured on the same basis as the indemnified item.
Reacquired Rights: Valued based on the remaining contractual term of the related contract, ignoring potential market participant renewals.
Unamortized debt issuance costs are not carried forward.
Income Taxes (ASC 740): Measured and recognized in accordance with ASC 740.
Employee Benefits (ASC 715): Measure assets and liabilities related to the acquiree’s employee benefit plans in accordance with ASC 715.
Share-Based Payment Awards (ASC 718): Measured using the method prescribed in ASC 718 for awards exchanged or replaced in a business combination.
Assets Held for Sale (ASC 360-10): Measured at fair value less costs to sell.
Contingencies (ASC 805-20): Recognize acquired contingent assets and liabilities at acquisition-date fair value when that value can be determined during the measurement period. Otherwise, apply the acquisition-date recognition criteria in ASC 805-20-25-20, including whether an asset or liability probably existed and its amount can be reasonably estimated. Items that do not meet those criteria are subsequently accounted for under applicable guidance, including ASC 450.
3. Reporting Practices.
A common question when integrating newly acquired subsidiaries is: how do I approach investees that provide only financial statements (or a trial balance) without full access to, or integration with, the general ledger? This is relevant for many foreign subsidiaries that manage books locally.
As part of an integration process, we want to understand:
How homogeneous is the subsidiary’s operation compared to the rest of the business operations?
What level of synergies was expected when the transaction was planned?
What is the extent and complexity of local statutory filings and reporting?
How feasible is it to reallocate bookkeeping responsibilities, in full or in part, to a centralized accounting team?
How feasible is it to train local teams to use the parent’s ERP system for day-to-day accounting vs. importing local trial balances monthly from local ERP systems?
A shared ERP can simplify access to the subsidiary’s records and support intercompany reconciliations. However, a foreign legal entity will likely still need to file local statutory reports that do not reflect fair value basis adjustments and may be based on accounting policy choices inconsistent with the parent’s policies. Hence, the group must still decide where to maintain its acquisition-accounting adjustments, since the subsidiary’s books may follow a different accounting basis. The group may keep those adjustments in a consolidation reporting system, a separate reporting book, or spreadsheet documents. The most common approach is to have a subsidiary provide standard monthly reporting packages (spreadsheets designed for easy import into the group’s consolidation model) for consolidated reporting purposes.
3.1. Reporting Models
Three main operating models exist for integrating new subsidiaries into group financial reporting. In practice, most groups use one of these three models of implementing a new basis:
Centralized (Topside Adjustments) model based on central topside adjustments, where the subsidiary submits local numbers, and the parent converts them.
Decentralized (Reporting Package) model, where the group close tool embeds recurring conversions and support schedules.
Integrated System model, where the subsidiary ultimately records the parent-basis logic in its own ongoing reporting structure.
Below, we discuss each model in detail.
3.3.a. What is the “Centralized (Topside Adjustment)” Reporting Model?
The group team prepares consolidated information (including new-basis adjustments) centrally using statutory data. This is often the most practical when local management lacks US GAAP expertise. This approach is often best to use immediately after acquisition.
This model requires the group team to either have direct access to the local ERP system or have a strong process in place to collaborate effectively with local teams and access detailed accounting records on time. If this condition is met, parent-level consolidation procedures would use trial balances exported from local ERP systems already in place at the subsidiary. Alternatively, they would have to utilize statutory financial statements provided by individual subsidiaries (often resulting in lag-based accounting).
3.3.b. What is the “Decentralized (Reporting Package) ” Reporting Model?
This is the most common immediate post-close model. The subsidiary keeps its local ERP and books but submits a standardized package to the parent for monthly or quarterly consolidation. The subsidiary prepares that package using the standard group template. That template usually includes trial balance sheets, mappings, account rollforwards, intercompany schedules, cash flow support, disclosure questionnaires, and transformation adjustments tabs. The group team members often lack access to the subsidiary’s ERP system and rely exclusively on information reported in the subsidiary’s reporting packages.
3.3.c. What is the “Integrated System” Reporting Model?
This model is typically reserved for material or strategic subsidiaries where the parent wants durable standardization, but it can also be realized as a single integrated ERP system used consistently across the organization. Here, the subsidiary typically keeps multiple sets of books, with one set based on the acquisition-method balances. This is a resource-intensive path, and that is why many companies deliberately avoid it.
Sometimes, these models follow each other incrementally, from the least disruptive for a subsidiary’s company (#1) to the least disruptive for the parent’s company (#3).
In case you missed it….
4. Accounting Policies.
The PPA establishes the group’s opening balances and affects how the acquired subsidiary’s financial position is presented in subsequent consolidated reporting. Those balances then change through post-acquisition transactions and events. The accounting policies applied to that activity determine how the changes are recognized and measured and therefore shape the financial results the group reports.
Where the subsidiary applies different accounting policies, management must assess whether those differences can remain in consolidated reporting or require adjustments to conform to the group’s policies.
Under the US GAAP interpretation we follow, a subsidiary generally does not have to conform to the parent’s accounting policies, provided its policies are otherwise acceptable. However, harmonization is always advisable because it ensures consistent, comparable financial information.
A practical process for harmonizing policies typically includes the following steps:
Conducting a thorough inventory of all existing accounting policies across the parent and acquired entities,
Performing a gap analysis to identify and evaluate areas where the policies differ, and
Developing a harmonization action plan to address significant gaps, including a clear communication plan and implementation timeline. This often involves circulating updated policies, providing targeted training to relevant teams, and establishing ongoing monitoring to ensure the new policies are consistently applied.
Published US GAAP interpretations differ on which acceptable policy differences may remain in consolidated financial statements. Our position follows EY’s interpretation, meaning that different accounting policies are not prohibited. We nevertheless recommend documenting and disclosing each material difference and, where possible, conforming policies to reduce practice diversity.
4.1. What steps should be included in the policy conformity analysis?
The practical policy conformity analysis consists of:
Identifying differences from the Parent’s policies.
Establishing whether the subsidiary’s information is in accordance with US GAAP.
Identifying policies related to transactions the Parent had not previously encountered or that were immaterial in the Parent’s operations but are material for the acquiree. (The Parent’s adoption of those policies would not be considered a change in accounting principle. Following the same logic, these subsidiary’s policies are not considered non-conforming.)
Making consolidation adjustments where appropriate.
4.2. How do you conduct an interview with the acquiree’s accounting team?
To assess policy differences, management needs to understand which policies the subsidiary applies. Interviews with the accounting team or bookkeeping provider help establish that understanding. The discussions also help determine whether the local team can independently prepare the adjustments required for group reporting. During the interview, address the following matters:
What is the current composition of the accounting team?
Does the team’s size allow proper segregation of duties?
How are responsibilities split among team members?
What is the month-end close timeline?
What accounting and other systems of record are being used?
What are the main data sources used (ERP, HR, FX, Subledgers, etc.)?
Does the acquiree have written accounting policies?
Does the acquiree have formalized process narratives?
Does the acquiree have documented process risks and internal controls?
Does the team have formal materiality levels?
What is the structure of the acquiree’s chart of accounts?
What accounts have characteristics such as:
Material balances,
High transactional volumes,
Significant judgment involvement (estimates),
Changes in responsible employees
What are key types of arrangements with external parties?
What risks of material misstatement are viewed as significant (if any)?
What process bottlenecks exist?
Does the acquiree have the same fiscal year-end date?
Does the current accounting team have sufficient knowledge and experience to support the group’s management in consolidation processes?
Review the subsidiary’s chart of accounts to identify accounts that can be mapped directly to the group chart of accounts vs. accounts that require further detail. Where a local account consists of items that require different presentation under the group policies, obtain additional details or designate a formal methodology for allocation between objects of accounting.
Inspect a sample of transactions recorded to each account.
Obtain copies of any formal accounting policies or memos prepared by the acquiree (if any).
Establish a universal chart of accounts for all group entities, with mapping tables from each subsidiary’s accounts to the group’s format. A universal chart of accounts and mapping tables can significantly reduce consolidation time. Depending on the level of detail available, additional adjustments may be necessary. In some cases, certain acquiree accounts may correspond to multiple accounts in the group’s chart of accounts, and vice versa. Manage these scenarios with due consideration of the materiality of the underlying transaction classes and the company’s reporting requirements.
4.3. What are best practices to consider with regard to accounting policy governance?
Some other known good practices here involve:
Maintain a single authoritative source for all policies and make it available to the acquiree’s accounting team as early as possible. This may be accomplished through a shared website hosting the group’s accounting manual or a centralized policy repository.
Organize accounting and finance policy documents logically to support efficient retrieval and reference.
Implement version control to track changes to finance and accounting policies and support appropriate governance.
Establish a process that allows users to submit questions and request policy changes. Clearly communicate procedures for suggesting new policies or modifying existing policies, and administer them efficiently.
Use cross-references to minimize duplication of content and requirements, directing users to related material in other policy documents as appropriate.
Conclusion
The first consolidation presents many challenges. Today, we discussed:
Accounting models that may apply to an acquisition.
Basics of the purchase price allocation process.
A practical framework for post-acquisition accounting and ongoing reporting.
Differences between the seller’s and buyer’s accounting policies.
These topics cover only a small part of the accounting requirements and transaction-specific judgments that management must address in an M&A transaction. We will examine further questions in our future articles.
Rare Gems
[1] A guide to accounting for business combinations by RSM, Appendix A: The acquisition-accounting checklist.
[3] Planning for Multi-Book Accounting, by Oracle NetSuite
[4] Accounting Context, by Oracle NetSuite
[5] Accounting for restructuring costs, Agenda Paper 2B, by IASB
[6] When Culture Doesn’t Translate: How to expand abroad without losing your company’s mojo, by Erin Meyer
[7] Research: How Speech Patterns Shape Opportunity at Work, by Avery Forman
[8] Outlining Consolidation With Group Reporting, by SAP
Strategic Accounting with Andrei
Want to learn about integrating business strategy into your accounting process? Curious about the latest guidance? Or maybe you just want to get quick wins?
Our newsletter offers real insights from practitioners. If you have a topic you’d like to discuss, book some time with me!




